How to Reduce Risk in Your Commercial Property Portfolio

Item: Ellis David
Rating: 4.7
Author: Ellis David

A single undeclared flat above a shop can undo a portfolio's insurance programme. Most portfolio risk is like that — small, procedural and expensive, and it surfaces at the worst possible moment.

One unit or forty, the exposures are the same in kind; they just scale differently. This guide sets out where the avoidable losses actually come from, and what to do about them.

London Stock Has Its Own Problems

If your portfolio is in London, several things are working against you at once.

Much of the commercial stock is Victorian or Edwardian, frequently converted, often with flats above shops and restaurants — the mixed-use configuration insurers price most cautiously. Terraced frontages mean a fire or an escape of water rarely stops at your boundary. Access is restricted, so reinstatement takes longer and costs more than the same work outside the M25. Large parts of the capital sit on shrinkable London Clay, which is why subsidence excesses here are routinely higher than elsewhere, and parts of the Thames floodplain carry flood terms that vary street by street.

None of that makes London property uninsurable. It does mean that a policy bought on price alone, from an insurer without appetite for the stock, tends to come apart at the first substantial claim.

Know What Is Actually in the Portfolio

Every property presents different challenges depending on its location, occupancy, tenant profile and trade. A retail unit on the ground floor of a mixed-use building faces different risks from an office block or an industrial warehouse.

The common exposures are:

Fire and flood damage
Escape of water
Break-ins and theft
Malicious damage
Loss of rental income
Liability claims from visitors, contractors or tenants
Unoccupied periods
Regulatory and compliance breaches
Rising maintenance and repair costs

A portfolio mixing commercial and residential assets carries all of these, in different proportions per property. Knowing which applies where is the first step.

Declare Everything

The single cheapest risk-reduction measure is an accurate schedule.

Make sure every unit is declared — commercial and residential alike. An undeclared flat above a shop is a gap waiting to be found at claim, and a change of tenant trade that nobody told the insurer about can be worse: a policy written for a florist responds differently once the unit is a takeaway.

Tell your insurer when occupancy changes, when a unit is refurbished, when a tenant's trade changes, and when a property empties.

Get the Rebuild Costs Right

Many property investors focus on market value when arranging building insurance, but insurers are more concerned with rebuild costs.

If the portfolio is underinsured, a major loss can result in a reduced settlement, leaving you funding the balance. Most commercial policies contain a condition of average: insured for 80% of the rebuild cost, and 80% of the claim may be paid.

Reassess rebuild costs regularly, and always for:

Older buildings
Listed properties
Mixed-use developments
Properties that have been refurbished or converted
Anything where the figure has simply been index-linked for several years

Indexation keeps a correct figure roughly current. It does not fix a figure that was wrong to start with. Our guide to calculating rebuild costs explains what should be included.

Watch Risk Concentration

Concentration is worth understanding as an insurance question, not only an investment one. A portfolio made up entirely of one property type, in one location, let to tenants in one sector, is exposed to a single event or a single market shift across the whole book — and insurers price and structure cover accordingly.

Spread across locations, tenant sectors, property types and lease structures reduces that concentration. Where it exists, it is worth discussing with your broker, because it affects both the terms available and how a programme is best arranged.

This is general information about property risk, not investment advice. Ellis David is an insurance broker; speak to a regulated investment adviser about portfolio strategy.

Vet Your Tenants

Your tenants drive the performance of the portfolio, and a financially unstable tenant creates missed payments, property neglect and legal costs.

Before agreeing a lease, assess credit history, trading performance, the outlook for their industry, previous landlord references and their business plans. Understand exactly what trade will be carried on, because that is what your insurer is pricing.

Strong tenant relationships also encourage early reporting of maintenance problems that would otherwise become claims.

Protect the Rental Income

For most investors, rent is the whole point of the portfolio, and fire, flood or storm damage stops it.

Most commercial landlord and commercial property policies can include rent protection — cover for the income lost while insured damage is put right. Two things determine whether it works:

The sum insured should reflect the current annual rent roll, not historic receipts.
The indemnity period should reflect how long reinstatement would realistically take. Reviewing rent indemnity periods regularly keeps the protection adequate for longer reinstatement projects, and twelve months is frequently too short for a London building where planning, access and specialist trades all add time.

This matters most where borrowing is secured against the properties, because the lender's expectations do not pause while the building is rebuilt.

Maintain the Buildings

Preventative maintenance is far cheaper than emergency repair, and insurers notice the difference.

Routine inspections catch water ingress, structural defects, roof deterioration, electrical faults and plumbing failures before they escalate. Keep clear records of inspections and repairs — they demonstrate responsible ownership, they support your position at renewal, and they answer the question insurers ask first when an escape of water claim looks like gradual damage.

Take Unoccupancy Seriously

Properties empty during refurbishment, between lettings or through market conditions, and vacant buildings attract vandalism, theft, squatting, water damage and fire.

Insurers apply strict conditions to vacant buildings — typically weekly inspections, isolated and drained services, and a restricted list of perils. Failing to tell your insurer when a property empties can leave you without cover at the point you need it most. This is the most commonly disputed point in commercial property claims, and it is entirely avoidable.

Specialist unoccupied property cover can protect vacant assets while refurbishment or reletting takes place. See our unoccupied commercial property insurance page.

Run Proper Health and Safety

Property-related liability claims are expensive, and the defence costs land whether or not you were at fault.

Keep on top of:

Fire risk assessments
Emergency lighting checks
Asbestos management
Lift inspections
Electrical testing
Slip and trip prevention

Public liability cover protects you against claims from visitors, contractors and members of the public injured at your properties.

If you directly employ anyone to manage or maintain your properties — including part-time caretakers or cleaners — employers' liability insurance is a legal requirement under the Employers' Liability (Compulsory Insurance) Act 1969. A small number of exemptions exist; do not assume you fall inside one.

Review Mixed-Use Exposures

A mixed-use property introduces particular considerations, because commercial and residential space sit in the same building.

A shop with flats above exposes the owner to risks affecting both commercial tenants and residential occupants, and the trade downstairs drives the terms for the whole building.

When insuring mixed-use property, make sure the policy reflects:

The commercial trading activities actually carried on
The number of residential units
Shared access areas
Occupancy arrangements, including any empty units
Building construction

A single well-structured policy is usually easier to manage than separate arrangements, and avoids arguments about which insurer responds to damage that crosses the boundary between the two uses.

Review Your Cover Every Year

The insurance market moves, and many investors renew automatically without testing whether the cover still fits.

A fresh look each year lets you:

Review policy limits and indemnity periods
Compare wordings, not just premiums
Check insurer appetite for your stock
Re-examine exclusions and conditions
Reflect what has changed in the portfolio

We check insurer financial strength before we recommend a policy — you should not have to.

Comparison platforms price a standard risk quickly. A portfolio with mixed-use blocks, listed buildings or unoccupied units is not a standard risk, and the differences that matter are in the wording, not the premium. The cheapest policy is not always the most suitable.

Protect Your Portfolio with Ellis David

Managing a commercial property portfolio well means anticipating problems rather than reacting to them: accurate declarations, realistic rebuild costs and indemnity periods, disciplined maintenance, and cover placed with an insurer that understands the stock.

Ellis David has arranged commercial property cover from Essex Road in Islington for around 50 years. We know London stock — mixed-use blocks, conversions, listed frontages, shops with flats above — and we hold agencies with more than 100 UK insurers and MGAs, giving access to over 1,000 products and schemes. We take the time to understand your portfolio, identify potential risks, and tell you plainly where the cover matches and where it does not.

Get in touch to talk it through.

This article is general information, not a personal recommendation. All cover is subject to the terms, conditions, limits and exclusions of the policy. Ellis David Ltd is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority, register number 442066.

Have you ever been convicted of any offences involving fraud, theft, false accounting or other dishonesty or an offence (whether or not in the United Kingdom) relating to companies, building societies industrial and provident societies, credit unions, friendly societies, insurance banking or other financial services, insolvency consumer credit or consumer protections, money laundering, market manipulations or insider dealing? (required)	YesNo
Are you the subject of any current criminal proceedings? (required)	YesNo
Have you any convictions for any offences other than those listed in question 1 a) above which are not spent, whether or not in the United Kingdom (excluding traffic offences unless these resulted in a ban from driving or involved driving without insurance)? (required)	YesNo
Are you or have you ever been the subject of any civil proceedings, arbitration or litigation, including proceedings that resulted in a County Court Judgment (CCJ) or other judgement debts, in the United Kingdom or elsewhere? (required)	YesNo
Are you aware of any intention to begin such proceedings against you in the future? (required)	YesNo
Do you have any judgement debts (including CCJs) made under a court order still outstanding, whether in full or in part? (required)	YesNo
Have you ever failed to satisfy any such judgement debts within one year of making of the order (required)	YesNo
Are you or have you ever been, the subject of any bankruptcy proceedings, or proceedings for the sequestration of your estate? (required)	YesNo
Have you ever entered into a deed of arrangement or an individual voluntary arrangement (or in Scotland a trust deed) or other agreement in favour of your creditors, or are you doing so? (required)	YesNo
Have you ever been found guilty of conducting any unauthorised regulated activities or been investigated for possible conduct of unauthorised regulated activities? (required)	YesNo
Are you, or have you ever been, the subject of an investigation into allegations of misconduct or malpractice in connection with any business activity? (required)	YesNo
Have you ever, either in the United Kingdom, or elsewhere been - (required)
- refused entry to, or been dismissed or requested to resign from, any profession, vocation, office or employment, or from any fiduciary office or position of trust, whether or not remunerated? (required)	YesNo
- refused, restricted in, or had suspended, the right to carry on any trade, business or profession for which specific licence, authorisation, registration, membership or other permission is required? (required)	YesNo
- disqualified by a court from acting as a director of a company or from acting in a management capacity of conducting the affairs of any company, partnership or unincorporated association? (required)	YesNo
- the subject of a disqualification direction under section 59 of the Financial Services Act 1986 of a prohibition order, under section 56 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, or received a warning notice to make such a direction or order? (required)	YesNo
Have you ever been a controller, director, senior manager, partner or company secretary of a company, partnership, or unincorporated association? If you answered "no" to question 8 you may proceed to section 12. Please tick (required)	YesNo

In respect of activities regulated by the FCA have you, or any company, partnership or unincorporated association of which you are or have been a controller, director, senior manager, partner or company secretary, during your association with that entity and for a period of three years after you ceased to be associated with it, ever - (required)
- been refused, had revoked, restricted or terminated any licence, authorisation, registration, notification, membership or other permission granted by any such body? (required)	YesNo
- been criticised, censured, disciplined, suspended, expelled, fined, or been the subject of any other disciplinary or intervention action by any such body? (required)	YesNo
- resigned whilst under investigation by, or been required to resign from, any such body? (required)	YesNo
- been the subject of any civil action which has resulted in a finding against you or it by a court? (required)	YesNo
Has any company, partnership or unincorporated association for which you have been a controller, director, senior manager, partner or company secretary, in the United Kingdom or elsewhere, at any time during your involvement or within one year of such an involvement – (required)
- been put into liquidation, wound up, ceased trading, had a receiver or administrator appointed or entered into any voluntary arrangement with its creditors? (required)	YesNo
- been declared by a court liable for any fraud, misfeasance, wrongful trading or other misconduct? (required)	YesNo
- been investigated or been involved in an investigation by an inspector appointed under companies or any other legislation, or required to produce documents to the Secretary of State, or any other authority, under any such legislation? (required)	YesNo
- been convicted of any criminal offence, censured, disciplined or publicly criticised, by any inquiry, by the Takeover Panel of any other governmental or statutory authority or any other regulatory body (other than as already indicated under 10 b))? (required)	YesNo
Are you currently a director of any company other than one which is a part of this company? (If “yes” please give details on the supplementary sheet). (required)	YesNo

How to Reduce Risk in Your Commercial Property Portfolio

London Stock Has Its Own Problems

Know What Is Actually in the Portfolio

Declare Everything

Get the Rebuild Costs Right

Watch Risk Concentration

Vet Your Tenants

Protect the Rental Income

Maintain the Buildings

Take Unoccupancy Seriously

Run Proper Health and Safety

Review Mixed-Use Exposures

Review Your Cover Every Year

Protect Your Portfolio with Ellis David

Ellis David Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.

Contact

152-154 Essex Road, London, N1 8LY

020 7354 3881

enquiries@ellisdavid.com

Links

Other

Your Details

Company Details

Good Repute Fit and Proper Form

Good Repute Fit and Proper Form